The first assignment or... killing babies!

Okay, I will admit to some sensationalism (just a little) but hey, one must draw readers some how, right?  :)  But this first assignment doesn't have to do with abortion, rather it has to do with the killing of a conjoined twin.

During Chapter One of our textbook, Rachels (the author, not my wife) discusses the case of two conjoined twins - Jodie and Mary - whose parents objected to an operation that would separate them at the risk of killing one or both of their daughters.


Please discuss this example.  Include a discussion of all those whose interests are at stake, and what those interests are.  Discuss your understanding of the Lord Justice's reasoning (as presented by Rachels); in your view does this reasoning adequately address the objections of the parents?

Below is what I plan to hand in on Wednesday.  Feel free to comment and/or offer corrections!